Interesting Though Elementary

Open to Criticism [MISS]

Friday, July 16, 2021

As long as Sherlock Holmes has been depicted in media, there have been critics of the actor portraying him or the writing he’s working with.  Plenty of folks have complained about three current ones: Henry Lloyd Hughes, Henry Cavill, and Will Ferrell.  

But some actors are above criticism, right?  Basil Rathbone is such an iconic image: the curved pipe, bumbling Watson, the deerstalker, etc.  First donning the Inverness cape in 1939, Rathbone is the indelible image of Holmes for many, many people out there.

(Quick caveat here: I’m not a big movie or TV watcher and have only seen one or two Rathbone films.  I’m not qualified to have an opinion on Rathbone’s portrayal.  If you are interested in the history of Sherlock Holmes in cinema, check out Ashley Polasek’s Being Sherlock or Howard Ostrom’s Sherlock Holmes on Screens.)

I was reading a collection of essays by Chicago Sherlockians, Sir Hugo’s Literary Companion, and came across a 1947 Chicago Review article.  In it, Jack Siegel referred to Rathbone’s radio portrayals of Holmes as “rot”.  He goes on to say about the movies:

“The movies too have stepped beyond the bounds set up by Dr. Watson, even to the point of bringing the date of Holmes’ fancied exploits up to the present time and presenting him as nothing more than another “G-man” hero.  Despite the sympathetic performances of Mr. Rathbone and Mr. Bruce, such tampering with facts and characters leaves a bad taste in the mouths of those who revere the real Holmes.”

I’m also working my way through all of the back issues of The Baker Street Journal.  The last few I’ve read are from the early 90’s and it’s interesting to see people be critical of the Jeremy Brett version as well.  So even though some things are remembered fondly, if you look close enough, there are critics in the weeds.

My take away from this is that no matter how good, important, brilliant, or whatever the interpretation is, there’s going to be critics.  You may as well enjoy what you like in spite of them.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

The Wisteria Lodgers: The Sherlock Holmes Society of Edmonton


Some Photoblog

Some pictures must be taken, some things must be blogged. Photography and pop culture.

18 Cinema Lane

A great place for talking about movies!



The Baz

for fans of the great Basil Rathbone

SHM - Das Sherlock Holmes Magazin

Für die Fans des großen Meisterdetektivs

Colin Garrow

Murder Mystery Horror Innuendo

Create your website with
Get started
%d bloggers like this: